White
Swan, Black Swan by Adrienne Sharp.
Random House, 2001. $21.95 — 208 pp.
Rules For Aging by Roger Rosenblatt.
Harcourt, 2000. $8.95 — 160 pp.
Adrienne
Sharps opening story in White Swan, Black Swan sets the tone
and the theme for the rest of the short stories in this collection.
In this story, Bugaku, Sharp tells us of a young dancer,
Joanna, who is on the verge of stardom in the ballet. When we meet
Joanna, she is irritated with her boyfriend, another dancer named
Ridley, who is the star of a dance company when they meet. As Ridleys
fortunes begin to sink and Joannas to rise, we see through
her eyes her own shift toward independence from Ridley while Ridley
himself begins to cling more closely to her. The last few lines
show us both their fates and the fact that Sharps writing
style is — well, sharp:
The audience takes a collective breath. I let my head roll back.
Then my arms. My tiny headdress grazes the floor, and from this
inverted, disorienting posture, I see Ridley staring at me from
the wings. His expression is hard to fathom, and for a moment, as
Nilas rotates me almost parallel to the floor and almost at its
level, I try to fathom it. But then Nilas is pulling me upright,
pulling me further into the dance, and I dont look for Ridley
again.
All of the other stories in White Swan, Black Swan are also concerned
with the ballet. Whether looking at the immortals of the ballet
and modern dance — George Balanchine, Margot Fonteyn, Mikhail
Baryshnikov, and a half-dozen other well-known dancers and choreographers
— or at the unknowns and the failures, Sharp blends together
her knowledge of ballet and her writing skills to give us insight
into the minds and hearts of her characters.
My own personal favorite story in this collection was Wili.
Katherine, who has danced in a professional ballet company for five
years, is slowly arriving at the realization that her dancing days
are numbered and that she will never be more than a wili,
which basically requires me to stand on one foot with the other
one pointed behind me for about the whole of Act II. Fighting
constantly with her boyfriend, taking drugs to help her perform,
Katherine finds that her only place of comfort is with her widowed
sister and her sisters 4-year-old daughter. Through Katherines
examination of her life and that of her bereaved sister, we see
the effects of failure and of ways to come to grips with that failure.
Katherine says of her sister Alison, whose husband died so young
and who must now sell her home, that Im rich suddenly,
with grief, for what she thought her life would be. Its not
her fault, its not what she deserves, but its what she
has to take instead. Such a bit of wisdom, so utterly true
and yet so frightening to many of us, makes the reader achingly
aware of lifes vicissitudes and our own personal failures.
Readers more familiar with the ballet than I will doubtless take
a good deal of interest in stories such as Don Quixote,
The Immortals: Margot + Rudolf 4 Ever, and A Short
Season. In these stories Sharp blends reality and fiction
as she looks at the lives of various stars from the world of ballet.
Ballet fans and lovers of good storytelling will find much to appreciate
in Adrienne Sharps White Swan, Black Swan.
Readers who are looking for some post New Years moral instruction
humorously presented should turn to Roger Rosenblatts Rules
For Aging. Rosenblatt gives us 58 rules to help us live longer and
to enjoy it more while were at it.
Take rule 40, for example: A long and happy life lasts five
minutes. No one likes to hear such a thing, of course, yet
Rosenblatt points out that many people actually believe that a long
life of uninterrupted happiness is a real possibility. Happiness
is wonderful, Rosenblatt says, but if youve had more
than five consecutive minutes of it, it means that you werent
thinking.
Rule 47: Culture Rules states:
See no movie that has been called exquisite
Read no novel that has been called brave
Attend no concert that has been called long, but worth every
minute.
Attend no opera that begins with the word Der.
Attend no other opera.
Several of the rules urge readers to look outward rather than inward
in order to live a longer, more contented life. Though he presents
these rules in a breezy, witty manner, Rosenblatt understands that
we inhabit a world in which we tend to focus on ourselves. Rule
2, for instance, states, Nobody is thinking about you.
Rule 8 gives Dylan Thomass old dictum: If someone is
boring you, its probably you. Rule 37 — The
waitress is not waiting for you — reminds older men
that 20-year-old women are not waiting with bated breath to date
them. Rule 42 — The unexamined life lasts longer
—contradicts Socrates, but Rosenblatt is making the point
that we need to look outward as well as inward.
If youre looking for some light but instructive reading, or
simply for a birthday present for a colleague or friend, try Rules
For Aging.
(Jeff Minick is a teacher and writer who lives in Waynesville.
He can be reached at saintsbookco@aol.com)