| |
<< Back
12/11/02
The
art of snobbery and the curse of profane language
By
Jeff Minick
Snobbery:
The American Version by Joseph Epstein.
Houghton Mifflin, 2002. $25 — 288 pp.
Cuss Control by James V. OConnor.
Three Rivers Press, 2000. $12.95 — 239 pp.
Joseph
Epstein, who has taught at Northwestern University since 1974 and
who served as editor of The American Scholar for 22 years, is one
of the great essayists of our time. Though not particularly well
known to the general public, Epstein has written 13 books in the
last three decades, many of them being collections of his essays.
He has written on divorce, ambition, sports, ethnic groups, and
literature.
Now Epstein has written Snobbery: The American Version. As in his
other books — I have read only A Line Out For A Walk, The
Middle Of My Tether, and Ambition — Epstein writes clearly
and concisely, draws frequently from personal experience, and leaves
the reader feeling both entertained and informed.
Epstein begins Snobbery by telling us of his own experiences with
snobs and snobbish behavior, including some of his own excursions
into snobbery. Epstein writes:
But, pathetic truth to confess, I am also a little pleased that
my son went to Stanford, for nothing better, I fear, than snobbish
reasons. I am too often a little pleased with myself on other snobbish
fronts. Allow me to present a few candid snapshots. Here I am giving
a lecture at an English university — how nice! Here I am being
praised in print by a writer I have long admired in a magazine of
high status — splendid! Here I am being paid obeisance by
the wealthy— and lo, the world seems a just and good place!
Epstein then comes up with a working definition of a snob as
...someone out to impress his betters or depress those he takes
to be his inferiors, and sometimes both; someone with an exaggerated
respect for social position, wealth, and all the accouterments of
status; someone who accepts what he reckons to be the worlds
valuation on people and things, and acts — sometimes cruelly,
sometimes ridiculously — on that reckoning; someone, finally,
whose pride and accomplishment never come from within but always
await the approving judgment of others.
For the rest of the book, Epstein turns to an analysis of different
types of snobs. He discusses job snobs (artists, even unsuccessful
artists, and entrepreneurs hold sway these days); class snobs (Members
of the so-called educated class really think of themselves as the
enlightened class); college snobs (Snobbery often resides
most comfortably where substance is absent, and for a long while
now snobbery has deeply infected higher education, among faculty
and students and parents alike); intellectual snobs (The
New York Review...was the journal of choice for those happy few...left-leaning,
right-living intellectuals, happily safe atop a cloud of nearly
celestial snobbery); wine and food snobs (bottles of bad wine,
writes Pierre-Antoine Rovani, with labels reading Grand Cru
or Pomerol can be sold in small quantities in
a place like New York, where there are lots of idiots).
With wit and literary insights and self-honesty, Epstein dissects
snobbery and lets us see why it exists and why human beings find
it so important. As he states in the bibliography, he draws heavily
on his own experiences, both with people and with books. He has
a wonderful way of sometimes surprising the reader, of literally
making him stop, of making a light bulb pop over his head. Near
the end of his book, for example, Epstein writes that in his everyday
actions he is not a snob. He is snobbish, he says, only in his thoughts
and how he views other people. This is the sort of snobbishness
practiced and felt, I suspect, by many of us.
If the recipient didnt take it amiss, this book simply by
the quality of its insights and style would make a fine Christmas
gift.
The other day, while watching a PG movie with my seven-year
old son, I was struck by how much swearing went into the film. The
actors used the word ass a score of times, d—n three times,
s—t several times, and G-d—n once.
There were times in my life when swearing was commonplace. In the
seventh and eighth grade I went away to a military school where
we swore as easily as we breathed. The habit I acquired then, one
that was later reinforced by college, has never completely left
me, so that to this day, when I am under pressure, oaths and cuss
words all too readily come to my lips. Indeed, I greatly fear dying
some day in an automobile crash, for rather than meeting my Maker
with a prayer on my lips I am reasonably certain that I would be
shouting the S word at the top of my lungs.
Hollywood producers, your acid-tongued reviewer, and perhaps a loved
one in your own life might do well to heed Cuss Control, James V.
OConnors complete book on how to curb your cursing.
In this volume OConnor tells us what my mother used to tell
me, namely that people who swear all the time are only demonstrating
their limited vocabulary and their lack of imagination.
Suppose, OConnor asks, you say that a certain room looks like
s—t. What do you mean by that? What does it say about the
room? Is it messy? In need of a decorator or a coat of paint? And
what exactly does it say about you that you say that about the room?
OConnors chapter titled The F Word: Stop Me Before
I Say It Again reminded me of a time in Boston when I was
helping a friend move a piece of furniture. I knew that he enjoyed
using the F word, but from Boston out to the suburbs and back the
entire dialogue went like this: I am so f—-ing tired
of this f—-ing weather, man, it really f—-s me up, what
with my f—-ing sinuses and f—-ing nose. Man, you got
to watch the f—- out for the f—-ing drivers on this
f—-ing road, cause they are f—-ing crazy. Theyll
f—- you up if you f—-ing let them.
An hour of this dreary dialogue left me, as you may imagine, pretty
f—-ed up myself.
OConnor uses numerous testimonies from those who curse, who
dont curse, and who have given up cursing to make his points
about the inherent stupidity behind most of our swearing. He demonstrates
why cursing creates a poor image and how it corrupts the English
language. He explains why we feel the urge to swear and how we may
kick the habit. He also gives many alternatives to swearing.
Incidentally, OConnor also encourages you to read newspapers
such as the one you are reading because the newspaper is one medium
that still avoids profanity (and my apologies here to any readers
whom the above review offended; I tried to stay within the bounds
of good taste).
Its Advent right now, the time of anticipation before Christmas,
the season of comfort and joy, of goodwill toward all men. If youre
experiencing mall rage or road rage or in-law rage or some other
rage, and if youre giving way to that rage with an over-reliance
on swear words, pick up a copy of OConnors book, follow
its wise precepts, and join the season.
(Jeff Minick lives in Waynesville. He can be reached at saintsbookco@aol.com)
|
|